Showing posts with label John Morrison. Show all posts
Showing posts with label John Morrison. Show all posts

Thursday, September 8, 2016

Retro Rowe: WWE Extreme Rules 2011 Review

WWE Extreme Rules

May 1, 2011

-From Tampa, FL. Our hosts are Josh Mathews, Booker T, and Jerry Lawler.

-Before the Randy Orton/CM Punk match begins, Josh Mathews announces that the General Manager computer has banned New Nexus members from ringside. If you’re going to have an obnoxious heel GM, just go all the way with it, don't have it randomly rule in favor of the babyface for no reason!

Last Man Standing:
Randy Orton vs. CM Punk

Punk removes some turnbuckle padding before entering the ring. Orton dominates the early brawl. Punk delivers a low kick and remembers that weapons are legal. Punk connects with some kendo stick shots. Back suplex by Punk isn’t enough to keep Orton down. Punk springboards into a kendo shot and Orton gets some revenge. Punk rebounds by catapulting Orton into the exposed turnbuckle. Punk props a chair in another corner but his bulldog attempt is countered. They trade finisher counters and Orton drives Punk into the chair! Orton bats Punk around ringside and nails a hard power slam! Punk is competitive but suffers a back suplex onto the barricade. Punk blocks the RKO in the ring and hits the GTS. Orton barely breaks the count so Punk administers a side Russian leg sweep onto a chair. Orton counters with the RKO out of nowhere. Punk survives long enough to wrap Orton’s head in a chair and drives him into the ring post! Punk attempts a GTS on the announce table but Orton counters with the RKO (but the table doesn’t break). They both struggle to their feet and Punk drops Orton onto the steps. Orton knocks Punk off the top ropes with a series of kendo shots. An RKO off the top rope finishes Punk at 20:00. A main event style brawl feels so out of place as an opener. The match was fine, I just had zero investment in this feud, ***.
Winner: Randy Orton

Monday, September 5, 2016

Retro Rowe: WWE Elimination Chamber 2011 Review

WWE Elimination Chamber

February 20, 2011

-From Oakland, CA. Our hosts are Michael Cole, Josh Mathews, and Booker T.

Alberto Del Rio (with Ricardo Rodriguez) vs. Intercontinental Champion Kofi Kingston

Del Rio cuts a promo beforehand, mainly insulting Oakland, bragging about his Rumble win, and destiny. Del Rio hides from an aggressive Kofi in the ropes as the fans chant for him. Ricardo distracts, allowing Del Rio to pop out of the corner and attack Kingston. Kofi retakes control briefly before Del Rio shoves him into the ring post. Del Rio establishes his control by driving Kingston into the ring steps. Alberto wears Kofi down for a while. Desperate flying cross body off the turnbuckles by Kofi. Kingston makes his patented comeback, complete with the Boom Drop. Trouble In Paradise misses, but Kofi improvises with a swinging kick. Del Rio counters a flying cross body. Missile drop-kick by Kingston gets 2. Gut buster by Alberto, but Kofi comes back with a swinging DDT. Ricardo distracts the referee, costing Kofi the win. The SOS connects for only 2. Del Rio counters with a neck breaker off the turnbuckles. The cross arm breaker ends it at 10:26. I like the chemistry here. Good opener, ***.
Winner: Alberto Del Rio

Retro Rowe: WWE TLC 2010 Review

WWE Tables Ladders and Chairs

by Samoa Rowe

December 19, 2010

-From Houston, TX. Our hosts are Michael Cole, Jerry Lawler, and Matt Striker. Cole is clutching his recently won Slammy awards.

Intercontinental Championship (Ladder match):
Dolph Ziggler © (with Vickie Guerrero) vs. Kofi Kingston vs. Jack Swagger

After a typical triple threat beginning, Ziggler is the first to attempt a climb. Kingston and Swagger have a brief exchange with the ladder before Dolph returns with a smaller ladder. Swagger seems to have injured his hand as Kofi takes a bad spill onto a ladder in the turnbuckles. Swagger returns to slingshot Ziggler into the bridged ladder. Kingston springboards through a ladder for a drop-kick. Ziggler sneaks in to deliver the fame-asser onto the ladder! With everyone down, Vickie climbs the ladder and Kofi tips it back. Ziggler pleads for mercy, but it’s Swagger that actually saves Vickie from taking a sick bump. Kofi manages to climb despite being stuck in Swagger’s ankle lock, and Ziggler climbs over all of them to almost get the belt. Kingston fights off a sleeper at the top and knocks Dolph down. Swagger prevents a Kofi victory and they trade shots and the Intercontinental title falls to the mat. Ziggler pounces on the belt and is declared victorious at 8:53. I’m going out on a limb to assume that was not the planned finish. This was quite an entertaining spot-fest until the abrupt finish, **¾.
Winner and still Intercontinental Champion: Dolph Ziggler

Retro Rowe: WWE Hell in a Cell 2010 Review

WWE Hell in a Cell 2010

by Samoa Rowe
October 3, 2010

-From Dallas, TX. Our hosts are Jerry Lawler, Michael Cole, and Matt Striker.

United States Championship (Submissions Count Anywhere):
Daniel Bryan © vs. John Morrison vs. The Miz

Looks like we’re getting this show off on the right note. Miz cuts a promo on his way to the ring bitching about how Bryan and Morrison wouldn’t have made it without him. Miz gets overwhelmed quickly and takes a break. He gets chased around the ring , forcing Morrison and Bryan to work together. Bryan and Morrison show off some chain wrestling while Miz is down. They roll to the floor with their legs locked and Miz finds an opening to attack both of them. Morrison ties Miz up in the ropes but Bryan breaks it up with a drop-kick. Bryan locks Cattle Mutilation on Miz! They reverse heel hooks in entertaining fashion until Morrison breaks it with Starship Pain. Morrison almost makes Bryan tap to a modified Haas of Pain and connects with a corkscrew plancha on Miz. They brawl into the crowd with Miz in the driver’s seat. Miz brings a production cart from the back and rams it into Morrison. Bryan gets placed on the cart and Miz drives it into the stage! Morrison counters and leaps over the cart for a drop-kick. Miz bounces back with the Skull Crushing Finale on Morrison on the concrete! Bryan and Miz square off on the stage and wipe each other out with clotheslines. Morrison climbs the lighting and perches on the cage wall on the stage. Morrison delivers a flying cross body onto the stage! Morrison applies a Texas Cloverleaf on Miz, but Alex Riley runs in for the save, tossing Morrison down the ramp. Bryan throws Riley into a cameraman. Bryan forces Miz to tap out to the Labell Lock at 13:30! I know I wasn’t paying close attention to WWE during this time, but I didn’t hear a thing about this match. This was a wildly inventive outing, worth checking out, ***¾.
Winner and still United States Champion: Daniel Bryan

Friday, September 2, 2016

Retro Rowe: WWE Summerslam 2010 Review

WWE Summerslam - August 15, 2010
by SamoaRowe

-From Los Angeles, CA. Our hosts are Michael Cole, Matt Striker, and Jerry Lawler.

Intercontinental Championship:
Dolph Ziggler © (with Vickie Guerrero) vs. Kofi Kingston

Ziggler is the newly crowned IC Champion, having won the belt from Kingston with an assist from Vickie. Kingston cuts off Vickie’s mic work before the match. Kingston wants revenge and is aggressive in the early going. Kingston misses a suicide dive and takes a nasty spill into the guard rail. Ziggler is eager for a count-out but to no avail. Ziggler goes to work on Kingston’s neck. Kofi dodges a corner splash and mounts a comeback. Ziggler rolls through a springboard cross body for a near fall. Fame-asser by Ziggler also gets 2. Kofi catches Dolph with his educated feet and delivers a flying shot to the head. Trouble in Paradise misses and Ziggler applies the sleeper hold! It’s about this time when the Nexus runs in and draws the DQ at 7:04! The group tosses Ziggler over the ropes and surrounds Kingston. This was a solid opener until the non-finish, **¼.
No contest.

Wednesday, August 31, 2016

Retro Rowe: WWE Elimination Chamber 2010

WWE Elimination Chamber

February 21, 2010

-From St. Louis, MO. Our hosts are Matt Striker, Michael Cole, and Jerry Lawler.

WWE Championship (Elimination Chamber):
Sheamus © vs. John Cena vs. Ted Dibiase vs. Randy Orton vs. Triple H vs. Kofi Kingston

Kingston checks his back during his entrance, a clever nod to him getting ambushed at last year’s event. Sheamus poses with the WWE title in front of each pod, which is pretty awesome. Sheamus and Kingston start the match and have a nice back and forth exchange. Kofi blocks a hip toss onto the steel and lands a high cross body. Sheamus takes control after hitting some back attacks. 5 minutes have passed and Triple H is let out of his pod. Triple H and Sheamus have a heated confrontation and a slugfest breaks out. HHH, the seasoned veteran, takes control. Triple H blocks the Celtic Cross and nails a DDT for 2. Kingston rejoins the fight with a cross body on Sheamus. Kofi unleashes Controlled Frenzy and the Boom Drop on Triple H on the steel. Sheamus gains control of Kofi. With 10 minutes gone, Randy Orton charges out of his pod and he cleans house on everyone. Orton repeatedly smashes Sheamus and then Triple H into the chain wall. Kingston wipes everyone out with a cross body over the ropes. Orton counters Kofi with a drop-kick. HHH squares off with Orton and eats a scoop slam. A flurry of near finishers breaks out. With over 15 minutes gone, Ted Dibiase joins the match. Dibiase considers whether or not to attack his mentor, Orton. Dibiase decides to help Orton back up and they start working together. Legacy forces Kofi’s head through the chain wall for a vicious attack. Legacy turns their attention to Triple H. Dibiase suggests that Orton deliver the spike DDT onto the steel and it connects! Dibiase and Orton stand outside Cena’s pod as it opens at the 21 minute mark. Cena fights his way out of the chamber and cleans house on Legacy. Cena drops Dibiase onto the steel with an Attitude Adjustment! Orton saves Dibiase from the STF and signals the RKO. Cody Rhodes runs in and slips a lead pipe to Dibiase. Typically, Dibiase accidentally clocks Orton with the pipe, before dropping Cena. Dibiase eliminates Orton at 23:55! Orton realizes what’s happened and gives Dibiase the “I’ll deal with you later” look before leaving. Sadly, Kingston plants Dibiase for an elimination at 25:25. Sheamus drops Kofi with a Brogue Kick. The Celtic Cross finishes Kofi at 26:06. Sheamus turns his attention to Cena and nails a backbreaker. Sheamus punishes Cena in a tree of woe. Triple H saves Cena from the Celtic Cross with a low blow. The Pedigree finishes Sheamus at 28:30! The WWE Champion has been eliminated! We’re down to Cena and Triple H. Cena locks on the STF and Triple H taps at 30:16. This was pretty tame by EC standards, but it told several stories and nicely set up a bunch of Wrestlemania matches, ***¾.
Winner and new WWE Champion: John Cena

Monday, April 14, 2008

The week of awesome!

April 8th-13th was a hell of a week. I know it might not seem like a big deal to some (especially those who were in Orlando for Wrestlemania weekend) but I managed to take in a WWE, ROH, and TNA event all in the same week.



On Tuesday, April 8th I went to the Smackdown/ECW tapings at TD Banknorth Garden in Boston, MA. This was an enjoyable experience. We got a nice dark match out of Jamie Noble vs. Kenny Dykstra. The crowd was hot for Noble, since he was the first babyface of the evening, and they worked a decent, albeit cookie cutter, bout. Noble went over.



ECW was a good show. The show opened with a very strong CM Punk/Miz match. It's funny to me that only within the last year some people were labeling Miz among the worst workers in WWE, and now he's developed into a strong midcard talent. There was no carry job by Punk here, it was just an all around good television match, clocking in around the *** mark.



Chavo Guerrero and Kane had their contract signing for Backlash. This was entertaining, and of course you can never appreciate Kane's pyro until it's blinded you in person. We also got to see the debut of Bam Neely, as he's Chavo's most recent crony. Chavo's frog splash onto Kane on the contract table was a sight to see, especially the brutal landing (Chavo's head and upper body hit the mat in a rather sickening way). This was by far the most "extreme" that the ECW broadcast got. Then again, complaining about how the current ECW really isn't ECW is just about as productive as tearing apart Michael Bay's Transformers for not being like the cartoon, so I digress.

Elijah Burke beat Nunzio in a short match. Not much to talk about here, I was excited to see Burke, but he didn't really do anything overly impressive here. They were still clearing the ring from the contract signing during Nunzio's entrance, and he acted all bossy, telling the crew to clear it faster for him, which was pretty funny.

Kofi Kingston beat Domino in another short match, which got enough time as to keep it from being classified as a complete squash. This was probably the most I've ever enjoyed Domino, as he turned in a good, aggressive performance. Kingston was pretty over with the live audience too, and he didn't botch half as many spots as I expected he would. If they play their cards right, there is no reason for Kingston to not become a big star (then again, he just might become another Carlito).

Main event was Tommy Dreamer vs. Colin Delaney. Dreamer's spot on the roster was on the line, as was a job for Colin. This was a decent match that was slightly more memorable thanks to the stipulation. It was nice to see Dreamer featured in such a prominent role.

Other side note, this would turn out to be the last episode with Joey Styles on commentary. The next week, we'd get the classic hilarity of Mike Adamle and his confusion.

Up next the referees came to the ring and changed the apron and ropes for Smackdown. The first segment was The Great Khali's "peace offerings" for Big Show. This included a live chicken and a goat. Somehow, my "goat of the year" chant didn't catch on. This was the most entertaining thing Khali has ever been a part of, and it was also the most over I've ever seen Big Show with a live crowd (and I've seen Big Show at numerous events). That Mayweather feud really did him a lot of favors.

John Morrison and The Miz beat Jimmy Wang Yang and Shannon Moore in a non-title match. My annoyance here was that if Morrison and Miz were going over anyhow, why not put the titles on the line? Anyhow, this was another solid match. The Miz really showed me a lot at this taping, as he turned in that good performance against CM Punk and then came out later and worked a second good match. And to think, just this time last year a lot of people regarded him as one of the worst workers on the roster.

Finlay (with Hornswoggle) beat Matt Striker. This was a comedy match, and was entertaining for what it was.

Victoria introduced Nattie Neidhart as "Natalya." This was a personal treat, as I've been a fan of Nattie's SHIMMER work for a while. This lead to a match pitting Victoria against Michelle McCool (who I also have a soft spot for). The match was your typical divas affair, but was suitable. Victoria is a solid hand, and Michelle is one of those diva search types who actually tries very hard to become competent in the ring.

Shawn Michaels and Batista faced off verbally in the ring. This was a fun segment, as Batista called Michaels out on the bullshit in his past. I must say, this feud is awesome, and is the best thing Batista has been a part of since his feud with Triple H. I really hope their Backlash match can deliver.

Vladimir Kozlov demolished Matt Logan. Kozlov fucked up his entrance by coming out too early and had to redo it. He's basically worthless too, this segment was dead.

Matt Hardy beat Chuck Palumbo in a solid match. It got a lot of time, and might have come off better on television, but was merely solid in the arena. MVP was on commentary for this one too. It was fun watching the set crew blow up his entrance tent.

There were "Undertaker" chants the entire night. A lot of fans had one track minds and really just seemed concerned with the Dead Man. Also, there were a series of vignettes of Vickie Guerrero and Edge out on a romantic evening (getting massages, naked in bed together).

The Undertaker beat Festus in an entertaining match. This worked because Festus is simply not allowed to act intimidated, so he gave Taker an all-out fight. If they were to build Festus up, they could really make a compelling feud out of that aspect. I know they won't, so in the mean time I'll just hope Jesse and Festus can get a run with the tag titles.

After the show, Edge and his buddies jumped Undertaker, which lead to Kane, Big Show, and Batista making the save. Just a fun run-in festival to top off the show.

So this is a really long post, so I'll have to add my ROH and Lockdown responses later on.

Saturday, March 22, 2008

Miz and Morrison = Decent WWE Tag Team Champions


I'll be the first to admit, when these two first won the belts I rolled my eyes. It was early in the era of Smackdown and ECW "exchanging talent" so it felt wrong that two ECW guys were now holding the Smackdown tag titles. Since they won the belts, they have primarily been featured on ECW, almost to the point where it feels like the titles switched brands all together. Miz and Morrison have joined a long list of tag team champions in the modern era where their reigns fall flat due to the lack of any tag division or real challengers. So far they have feuded with Shannon Moore and Jimmy Wang Yang, which produced a series of very solid television matches, but nothing that amounted to any heated pay-per-view appearances. Right now they seem to be doing the same in a rivalry against Jesse and Festus. On the bright side, Morrison and Miz work really well as a team and their matches are typically very solid, so despite them being thrown together, they are succeeding and doing the best they can in a rather sad situation.

Saturday, October 6, 2007

Why do we have three brands again?

I think everyone can agree that World Wrestling Entertainment is not having a good year by any means. After business had been on the rise for most of 2006 and early 2007, there have been many bumps in the road that have hurt the promotion. The most severe has to be the Benoit family tragedy, which hit the wrestling industry in general, and has brought attention to the drug problems in wrestling to congress. WWE is not making things any easier for themselves, and I will explain why.

I ask the question "Why do we have three brands anyway?" I have explored the stupidity that WWE incorporates when it comes to their three brands in past entries, but this is a subject that continues to bug me. Let's take a look at some problems they have had recently, and how the brand split should have helped them but didn't.

For starters, at the beginning of the summer, the WWE was running an elaborate "Who killed Mr. McMahon" angle. They were betting on this to be a big ratings draw, so they played out aspects of the angle on ECW and Smackdown as well, despite this being a Raw-centric angle. The problem was that this angle ate up so much time on ECW and Smackdown, that their own angles and roster were pushed to the side. Then the Benoit murders occurred and it became clear that it would be unwise to continue such an angle in this light. Good thing this was a Raw angle, so that only Raw will be hurt and the other two shows can continue on smoothly. Oh wait, the death angle swallowed ECW and Smackdown whole, they need regrouping too! What should have been an issue of replanning the next month of Raw's turned into an issue of replanning all three brands. This should not have happened.

Vince waited for a few weeks before returning to Raw. He quickly wrapped up the death angle, briefly explaining that he faked his own death to see how his family would react. On the same show, it was revealed that Vince had an illigitimate child. Another high profile Raw angle was born!

Oh, but wait! This angle ALSO spilled over to ECW and Smackdown. Vince and Coach started visiting all the brands in search of the illigitimate child, and the angle was now consuming ECW and Smackdown's angles as well! I suppose this is good and all, since absolutely nothing could happen to disrupt this angle... except that there was. The common understanding across the internet community is that the bastard son was going to be Mr. Kennedy, which would have been a great way to elevate him up the WWE ladder. This angle was going to make a new main event star, one that would likely take the WWE Championship and become a strong heel heading into Wrestlemania 24. It would have worked, except that a lengthy list of WWE superstars were busted of having been customers of an online steroid ring. This list decimated all three brands, as John Morrison, King Booker, Umaga, and Mr. Kennedy were included on the bust. So now, not only was the prime candidate for the bastard son role in need of a suspension, but so were many of the alternative ideas.

Once again, a high profile angle that engulfed all the shows had been disrupted greatly. WWE tried to salvage the situation by having the bastard son turn out to be Hornswoggle, so they could run a comedy angle rather than have it be an out-right flop by having the son turn out to be some unover midcarder that would not work in the main events. Again, this is something that should have only hurt Raw, but it hurt Smackdown as well. Hornswoggle was the Cruiserweight Champion, and had been associated with Finlay and feuding with Jamie Noble. Since he's been a McMahon, Hornswoggle has been cut off from both almost completely.

The hits just keep coming for WWE, as now the WWE Champion, John Cena, is hurt and needs 6-12 months to recover. Now there is a huge void at the top, and the No Mercy main event is up in the air. How can this be? Are there not two other brands besides Raw? Surely, Smackdown has a main event worth headlining? Oh wait, the Smackdown main event is Batista vs. Khali in a Punjabi prison match. This match has disaster all over it, when it was booked it was assumed that Cena/Orton III would be the main selling point of the show. Nevermind. Okay, so how about that ECW brand? Do they have a main event worth headlining No Mercy? Actually, they have CM Punk, who is doing the best he can with what they give him, against Big Daddy V. Never heard of Big Daddy V? He used to go by the name, Viscera. Yes, that Viscera. The unover, worthless, slug of a 90's burnout who has somehow managed to keep a job in WWE for the past three years. But this is typical of the ECW brand. On the last pay-per-view, Unforgiven, the ECW title match opened the show, and the challenger didn't even get a televised entrance. The ECW title is below midcard status now.

What makes matters even worse about the John Cena situation is that again this is something that should only be hurting Raw. But it isn't. The WWE is making sure that if Raw goes down, all the other brands go down with it. They've been heavily addressing how screwed they are over Cena on both ECW and Smackdown this past week. Lovely.

So, with three brands, isn't there some way that these problems could have been avoided? The death and bastard son angles should have stayed on Raw. There is no reason why ECW or Smackdown had to get involved. They would have acknowledged the loss of Mr. McMahon, but did we really need an episode of Smackdown where all the feuds were thrown to the side in favor of interbrand "tribute" matches? Then when the bastard son angle started, it should have been stated that the son was a Raw superstar, leaving the other two brands out. This is not a case of boosting the other shows because they have the aftermath of Raw's "grand" events. I don't see the Teddy Long heart attack incident all over Raw and ECW (aside from Smackdown rebounds, etc). If the same thing had happened to an authority figure on Raw, an entire episode of Smackdown would have been devoted to it.

In the case of John Cena's injury, the time used recapping it and fearing what the solution would be, they should have turned up the heat on ECW and Smackdown. They needed to let CM Punk cut a kick-ass promo over how he would step up as ECW champion and make No Mercy a night to remember. They should have allowed Tommy Dreamer to get the title shot instead of Viscera. There is invested emotional interest in Dreamer, because he's an original who just wants to be the ECW champion again. That would have been appealing, and the most credible ECW main event in months. On Smackdown, they should have tried harder to put Batista over as a mighty world champion. Instead, it was the same old shit.

So there you have it. There are three brands, but it seems that every storyline disruption on Raw has to hurt the other two. And at the same time, they keep Smackdown and ECW in such ruins that they cannot rely on them to step up when something goes wrong on Raw. If this is really how they plan on running the company, then it's time to just unify the roster again. Do Raw and Smackdown, and turn ECW into Velocity (keep Heat on WWE.com) with the same roster. It wouldn't look that much different now. Book a CM Punk/Batista/WWE Champion triple threat match where the winner gets all the titles and unify them at once. Either do this, or start being smart with the brand extension. WWE has had five years now to get it right, and they haven't, so something needs to change.

Tuesday, July 3, 2007

World Champions everywhere I turn.




World Wrestling Entertainment currently has three seperate brands (television shows) in the form of Raw, Smackdown, and Extreme Championship Wrestling. As a result, they have felt the need to craft a world championship for each brand. Raw currently has the WWE Championship, a title which has a lineage dating back to 1963 when Buddy Rogers won a fictional tournament in South America and became the WWWF Champion. This title is typically viewed as the real deal when it comes to world titles in WWE, due to it's history and even it's name would suggest "champion of WWE."
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Smackdown is currently home to the World Heavyweight Championship. Some argue that this is the old WCW Championship, and shares it's lineage. I would disagree, as even though the WCW title was renamed "The World Championship" in late 2001 (before being unified with the WWF Championship when Chris Jericho became the first ever undisputed champion), the title lineage was broken and restarted when Eric Bischoff handed the belt to Triple H in September of 2002. I believe it is better to just accept a new lineage for the current World Heavyweight Championship, mainly because the WCW belt was booked into oblivion in 2000, and it is better if we don't have to look at Vince Russo and David Arquette as former title holders to the belt currently held by Edge.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ECW is obviously the home of the ECW World Championship. This is generally considered to have the lineage of the ECW title from the original promotion. That can also be disputed because Rhino was the last title holder before the company folded in 2001, and was given the physical belt as a gift from Paul Heyman. The physical belt (held by Johnny Nitro) is actually a replica and not the original title. Rhino still has the old belt, though he is obviously not recognized as being the reigning champion of the last six and a half years.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So even though WWE has three brands, does each brand really need their own world title? Wouldn't it be better to have one champion who peforms on all the shows? Well, that was the idea at first. When the WWE first split into Raw and Smackdown brands in April 2002, the idea was that the Undisputed Champion would go everywhere. This concept had it's benefits. The Undertaker held the title for two months, but his reign felt much more fulfilling due to him simultaneously feuding with Jeff Hardy and Rob Van Dam on Raw, and with The Rock and Kurt Angle on Smackdown. There were also kinks, as Ric Flair making a main event at Backlash that year as Triple H defending the belt against Raw's Undertaker, with Vince McMahon changing the match to Triple H vs. Smackdown's Hulk Hogan a few days later. The problem there was with the writing, and obviously not the concept, but it was a rough way to kick things off. 2002 was a truly miserable year for WWE.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Having said that, I think it is possible for WWE to have three World titles within their company and to keep all three champions on the same level as one another. The problem though, is that they are not doing that. Soon after reviving the ECW title, the three title holders in WWE were John Cena, Big Show, and King Booker. These were three credible main eventers and worked as world champions. Then the ECW title was placed on Lashley, and the belt took a hit as it was clearly being used the way that secondary title belts should be used, to get a midcarder over. The trio of world titles rebounded from this after Undertaker won the Royal Rumble. They had John Cena, Lashley, and Batista (having won the World title from King Booker) on Raw, with Undertaker sizing each of them out. The mere possibility that Undertaker might have wanted to challenge Lashley for the ECW title as his prize for winning the Rumble did a lot to make the ECW title look good.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
But things have really gotten messed up since Wrestlemania 23. The WWE decided the best way to salvage their pay-per-view business was to make all the shows tri-branded. But doing this really kills the point of having three world champions. Before, when Raw had a pay-per-view, it would be headlined with a WWE title match. Smackdown pay-per-views would be headlined with a World title match. And ECW pay-per-views would be headlined by the ECW title. You see, a big part of keeping a title looking credible is to have the title defenses go on last on big shows, such as pay-per-views. If these so called World titles are regularly defended halfway through the show or so, they start to look like midcard titles.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Since Wrestlemania 23, John Cena has main evented every single pay-per-view, defending his WWE title. The ECW title has been a complete midcard act, as Lashley's feud with Vince McMahon and Umaga didn't really set the world on fire the way they had hoped (compare it to the heat the DX/McMahons feud, it doesn't hold up well at all). Meanwhile, Smackdown had a credible main event program in Edge vs. Batista, but all of their matches were forced to take a backseat to John Cena and the WWE title.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Now we all know that Raw is the flagship program. However, it will always be the flagship show at this point, so it actually benefits WWE to take measures to make the other two brands seem legit as well, as it will translate into higher ratings and better attendance. It would not be difficult to switch things out as far as where matches are placed on pay-per-view cards. For example, let John Cena defend the title in the main event at Backlash, let Batista and Edge go on last at Judgment Day, and let Lashley and McMahon go on last at One Night Stand. It would have made complete sense. The problem with WWE's pay-per-views right now is that they are making it appear that the WWE title is the only World title, the World title is the new Intercontinental title, and the ECW title is the new European title. Also, no Smackdown stars have main evented a pay-per-view since No Way Out in February, and as a result it is starting to seem that Smackdown has NO main eventers. Batista, Undertaker, Edge? All big stars, but none of them are being treated as main eventers outside of the television show. And the current ECW champion is Johnny Nitro, who has not been properly elevated to a main event status, and his title defenses will likely all be midcard attractions.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So in a nutshell, WWE needs to throw the other two brands a bone every now and then. The current formula is hurting them more than they could ever begin to comprehend.